-
Our Most Popular Episodes
Spotify is a little stingy with stats, but here’s a list of every episode with at least fifty plays. If you’ve missed any, hit that play button and catch up! March 28, 2026
-
Episode 186: Fifty States of Murder: Virginia
It’s double trouble as Fifty States of Murder takes on Black History Month with the 2002 Beltway Sniper duo of John Allen Muhammad and Lee Boyd Malvo. Not quite father and son, the two drove cross country in 2002 and ended the lives of seventeen victims, culminating in a national panic in October as the
-
Episode 185: St. Patrick’s Day Special: Wisconsin
It’s a buy-one-get-two-free triple threat this week as Eli and Mel nail St. Patrick’s Day, Black History Month, and Fifty States of Murder all at once with the harrowing tale of a mid-80’s murder spree that covered six states and left eight people dead. Alton Coleman and Debra Brown committed their brutal crimes during the
-
No episode this week
We have a script ready to go but we’re giving Eli’s voice a rest. Mel isn’t feeling too well either. Lozenges everywhere! We’ll be back with more Fifty States of Murder, belated Black History Month episodes, and maybe with a little Irish luck, a St. Patrick’s Day special. In the meantime, hit up the back
-
Episode 184: Fifty States of Murder: North Carolina
Get ready for a double-whammy Black History Month Fifty States of Murder DUSE-style extravaganza as Eli and Mel connect the dots to reveal the truth about one of the oldest and most violent cults in American history: the Black Hebrew Israelites. The first congregations were founded over a hundred years ago but the words of
It’s our mission to deliver the best “professional” coverage of evil both old and new. So crack a cold one and settle in while we tell you what’s REALLY going on with all those pesky aliens, serial killers, cryptids, monsters under the bed, and everything else that goes bump in the night.
New show every Monday morning!