What do mashed potatoes have to do with murder? Tune in and find out as Eli and Mel travel back in time to 1981 to investigate the family values of John Mathis, a mid-western pig farmer who may or may not have used a .22 caliber to re-enter the singles market. As a bonus for our loyal listeners Eli shares his top-secret recipe for garlic pudding. YUM! So if you’re about to ride a horse into a public fountain you better make sure it’s wearing pants in… South Dakota!
Music Credit: “Game Boy Horror” by The Zombie Dandies
Originally aired January 5, 2026